Not quite smooth as buttah…

So, I finally got around to watching this video which has been been making the rounds as of late (not a Rickroll, I swear to god! WHY DOES NO ONE TRUST ME?! :-). I fired it up the 1080p version in fullscreen mode, and was slightly disappointed to find that while the video was playing back rather well, it wasn’t quite perfect. As the beer commercials say, “rich, but not smooth.”

So I next loaded it up in Safari, to see how it compared. Previous versions of Firefox have had some jerky-video problems (due to running garbage collection at bad times or doing too much main-thread disk IO for session restore), so I was fully prepared to file a bug on the problem — smooth playback in another browser would be a strong indication that something in our code was causing the poor performance.

However, what I found was that playback in Safari was much much worse that on the trunk Firefox build I was using. While Firefox yielded good playback with an occasional glitch, Safari gave a consistently poor playback of around 3 fps.

There’s one clear, inescapable conclusion here: Flash sucks. :-) But seriously, folks, I’m happy to see that trunk builds perform well. I should still file a bug to investigate if we’re responsible for the occasional stutter in playback (or if that’s just Flash), and if results on Windows are similar to OS X or not. But I’m still pleased to see that this arbitrary trunk nightly — not even beta quality — is doing a good job.

About Justin Dolske

Mostly harmless.
This entry was posted in Firefox, PlanetFirefox, PlanetMozilla. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Not quite smooth as buttah…

  1. Oh, and you’re looking for the guy in Room 11:

    http://i.imgur.com/gNz2f.jpg

  2. For me (on Windows) the playback in Minefield isn’t perfect but pretty close. Having the plug-ins out of process seems to help. Note that the hardware isn’t exactly powerful, it’s rather a low-range CPU (performance-wise) and the typical notebook on-board graphics. Would be interesting to have the same thing as OGG for comparison.

  3. Ben says:

    Now if only the built-in video support worked as well as Flash does… On Windows in fullscreen mode it’s 3 fps indeed.

  4. Oskar says:

    It runs at 16-17fps on 3.7a2pre.
    I uses around 85% of processor. (AMD Athlon 4800+)
    I agree with Wladimir.
    It would be nice that OGG could do same or even better performance.

  5. Oskar says:

    It runs at 16-17fps on 3.7a2pre.
    I uses around 85% of processor. (AMD Athlon 4800+ X2)*
    I agree with Wladimir.
    It would be nice that OGG could do same or even better performance.

Comments are closed.