At the beginning of 2013, Mozilla’s MySQL databases were a mix of MySQL 5.0, Percona’s patched MySQL 5.1, Percona’s patched MySQL 5.5 and MariaDB 5.5. MySQL 5.1 was released in November 2008 – so at the beginning of the year, we still had databases with no new major features in 4 years. Currently we have almost all our databases at Oracle’s MySQL 5.6 – the only stragglers are our cluster running TokuDB and a few machines that are no longer in use. Here’s a graph showing the state of our machines – you can see that in the first half of the year we concentrated on upgrading our 5.0 and 5.1 servers to 5.5, and then in the second half of the year we upgraded everything to MySQL 5.6 (click on the image to get a larger version):
After running some tests, we determined that MariaDB 5.5 was the best option for us and our particular workload. For most of our servers, it did not matter whether we use Percona, MariaDB or Oracle’s MySQL, but our Bugzilla servers really benefited from MariaDB’s better subquery optimization, so we went with that. We had set up some Percona 5.5 servers over the spring/summer of 2012, when we moved some of our infrastructure to a new data center.
We upgraded to MySQL 5.5 to be on a recent version of MySQL. In the middle of the year, we had a choice – should we stay where we were, or should we upgrade? We had no particular directive from developers to upgrade for the new MySQL 5.6 features. However, we have been doing more and more digging into our systems, and we really wanted the performance_schema features so we could dig even more. We want to be able to parse queries in real-time, perhaps with Anemometer without having to take an offline log file and run pt-query-digest on it.
So, we chose to upgrade to MySQL 5.6. Unfortunately, there were no other GA products to test against – by mid-2013, neither MariaDB nor Percona had a GA 5.6 product, so our bake-off was functional only, not performance-related. Oracle’s MySQL 5.6 passed with flying colors, and so we proceeded to upgrade.
Now, we have a recent and consistent version of MySQL installed, that we can work with to gain insights into our systems. A pretty great goal to have been met for 2013!