about:memory DMD Firefox Memory consumption MemShrink

Measuring memory used by third-party code

Firefox’s memory reporting infrastructure, which underlies about:memory, is great. And when it lacks coverage — causing the “heap-unclassified” number to get large — we can use DMD to identify where the unreported allocations are coming from. Using this information, we can extend existing memory reporters or write new ones to cover the missing heap blocks.

But there is one exception: third-party code. Well… some libraries support custom allocators, which is great, because it lets us provide a counting allocator. And if we have a copy of the third-party code within Firefox, we can even use some pre-processor hacks to forcibly provide custom counting allocators for code that doesn’t support them.

But some heap allocations are done by code we have no control over, like OpenGL drivers. For example, after opening a simple WebGL demo on my Linux box, I have over 50% “heap-unclassified”.

208.11 MB (100.0%) -- explicit
├──107.76 MB (51.78%) ── heap-unclassified

DMD’s output makes it clear that the OpenGL drivers are responsible. The following record is indicative.

Unreported: 1 block in stack trace record 2 of 3,597
 15,486,976 bytes (15,482,896 requested / 4,080 slop)
 6.92% of the heap (20.75% cumulative); 10.56% of unreported (31.67% cumulative)
 Allocated at
 replace_malloc (/home/njn/moz/mi8/co64dmd/memory/replace/dmd/../../../../memory/replace/dmd/DMD.cpp:1245) 0x7bf895f1
 _swrast_CreateContext (??:?) 0x3c907f03
 ??? (/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/dri/ 0x3cd84fa8
 ??? (/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/dri/ 0x3cd9fa2c
 ??? (/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/dri/ 0x3cd8b996
 ??? (/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/dri/ 0x3ce1f790
 ??? (/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/dri/ 0x3ce1f935
 glXGetDriverConfig (??:?) 0x3dce1827
 glXDestroyGLXPixmap (??:?) 0x3dcbc213
 glXCreateNewContext (??:?) 0x3dcbc48a
 mozilla::gl::GLContextGLX::CreateGLContext(mozilla::gfx::SurfaceCaps const&, mozilla::gl::GLContextGLX*, bool, _XDisplay*, unsigned long, __GLXFBConfigRec*, bool, gfxXlibSurface*) (/home/njn/moz/mi8/co64dmd/gfx/gl/../../../gfx/gl/GLContextProviderGLX.cpp:783) 0x753c99f4

The bottom-most frame is for a function (CreateGLContext) within Firefox’s codebase, and then control passes to the OpenGL driver, which eventually does a heap allocation, which ends up in DMD’s replace_malloc function.

The following DMD report is a similar case that shows up on Firefox OS.

Unreported: 1 block in stack trace record 1 of 463
 1,454,080 bytes (1,454,080 requested / 0 slop)
 9.75% of the heap (9.75% cumulative); 21.20% of unreported (21.20% cumulative)
 Allocated at
 replace_calloc /Volumes/firefoxos/B2G/gecko/memory/replace/dmd/DMD.cpp:1264 (0xb6f90744
 os_calloc (0xb25aba16 (no addr2line)
 rb_alloc_primitive_lists (0xb1646ebc (no addr2line)
 rb_context_create (0xb16446c6 (no addr2line)
 gl2_context_create (0xb16216f6 (no addr2line)
 eglCreateClientApiContext (0xb25d3048 (no addr2line)
 qeglDrvAPI_eglCreateContext (0xb25c931c (no addr2line)
 eglCreateContext (0xb25bfb58 (no addr2line)
 eglCreateContext /Volumes/firefoxos/B2G/frameworks/native/opengl/libs/EGL/eglApi.cpp:527 (0xb423dda2
 mozilla::gl::GLLibraryEGL::fCreateContext(void*, void*, void*, int const*) /Volumes/firefoxos/B2G/gecko/gfx/gl/GLLibraryEGL.h:180 (discriminator 3) (0xb4e88f4c

We can’t traverse these allocations in the usual manner to measure them, because we have no idea about the layout of the relevant data structures. And we can’t provide a custom counting allocator to code outside of Firefox’s codebase.

However, although we pass control to the driver, control eventually comes back to the heap allocator, and that is something that we do have some power to change. So I had an idea to toggle some kind of mode that records all the allocations that occur within a section of code, as the following code snippet demonstrates.

context = glx.xCreateNewContext(display, cfg, LOCAL_GLX_RGBA_TYPE, glxContext, True);

The calls on either side of glx.xCreateNewContext tell the allocator that it should tag all allocations done within that call. And later on, the relevant memory reporter can ask the allocator how many of these allocations remain and how big they are. I’ve implemented a draft version of this, and it basically works, as the following about:memory output shows.

216.97 MB (100.0%) -- explicit
├───78.50 MB (36.18%) ── webgl-contexts
├───32.37 MB (14.92%) ── heap-unclassified

The implementation is fairly simple.

  • There’s a global hash table which records which live heap blocks have a tag associated with them. (Most heap blocks don’t have a tag, so this table stays small.)
  • When SetHeapBlockTagForThread is called, the given tag is stored in thread-local storage. When ClearHeapBlockTagForThread is called, the tag is cleared.
  • When an allocation happens, we (quickly) check if there’s a tag set for the current thread and if so, put a (pointer,tag) pair into the table. Otherwise, we do nothing extra.
  • When a deallocation happens, we check if the deallocated block is in the table, and remove it if so.
  • To find all the live heap blocks with a particular tag, we simply iterate over the table looking for tag matches. This can be used by a memory reporter.

Unfortunately, the implementation isn’t suitable for landing in Firefox’s code, for several reasons.

  • It uses Mike Hommey’s replace_malloc infrastructure to wrap the default allocator (jemalloc). This works well — DMD does the same thing — but using it requires doing a special build and then setting some environment variables at start-up. This is ok for an occasional-use tool that’s only used by Firefox developers, but it’s important that about:memory works in vanilla builds without any additional effort.
  • Alternatively, I could modify jemalloc directly, but we’re hoping to one day move away from our old, heavily-modified version of jemalloc and start using an unmodified jemalloc3.
  • It may have a non-trivial performance hit. Although I haven’t measured performance yet — the above points are a bigger show-stopper at the moment — I’m worried about having to do a hash table lookup on every deallocation. Alternative implementations (store a marker in each block, or store tagged blocks in their own zone) are possible but present their own difficulties.
  • It can miss some allocations. When adding a tag for a particular section of code, you don’t want to mark every allocation that occurs while that section executes, because there could be multiple threads running and you don’t want to mark allocations from other threads. So it restricts the marking to a single thread, but if the section creates a new thread itself, any allocations done on that new thread will be missed. This might sound unlikely, but my implementation appears to miss some allocations and this is my best theory as to why.

This issue of OpenGL drivers and other kinds of third-party code has been a long-term shortcoming with about:memory. For the first time I have a partial solution, though it still has major problems. I’d love to hear if anyone has additional ideas on how to make it better.

4 replies on “Measuring memory used by third-party code”

Alas, I don’t know how to implement that in a nice way. And even if I did, there are multiple cases like this, so having a “third-party code” bucket wouldn’t give us much more information than what we already get with “heap-unclassified”.

I’m curious if you mentioned this earlier and I overlooked it. Knowing that most of the residual heap unclassified is from 3rd party libraries that aren’t readily instrumentable makes it a lot easier to understand why adding more memory reporters had reached the point of no longer being worth the effort when AWSY was still showing ~15-20% that wasn’t identified.

As ever, it depends on the particular workload. Some of it is from third-party code, but other than that we’re just into the long tail now, so it’s hard to shift the needle.

Comments are closed.