Categories: Around the Web Firefox

Windows on ARM Users Need Browser Choice Too

For the past eight years, users and developers have enjoyed a Windows platform environment that offered users a choice of browsers to navigate their digital lives.  It wasn’t always that way. Prior to the launch of Firefox in 2004, there was really only one browser for Windows – Internet Explorer. Only IE and Firefox had meaningful market share on the Windows platform from 2005-2009. The choices further increased with the introduction of Chrome, and today users can choose from a wide range of browsers. It’s hard to imagine what it used to be like. Unfortunately, the upcoming release of Windows for the ARM processor architecture and Microsoft’s browser practices regarding Windows 8 Metro signal an unwelcome return to the digital dark ages where users and developers didn’t have browser choices.

It’s reported that Windows RT (the name Microsoft has given to Windows running on the ARM processor)  will have two environments, a Windows Classic environment and a Metro environment for apps. However, Windows on ARM prohibits any browser except for Internet Explorer from running in the privileged “Windows Classic” environment. In practice, this means that only Internet Explorer will be able to perform many of the advanced computing functions vital to modern browsers in terms of speed, stability, and security to which users have grown accustomed. Given that IE can run in Windows on ARM, there is no technical reason to conclude other browsers can’t do the same.

Why does this matter to users? Quite simply because Windows on ARM -as currently designed- restricts user choice, reduces competition and chills innovation.  By allowing only IE to perform the advanced functions of a modern Web browser, third-party browsers are effectively excluded from the platform. This matters for users of today’s tablets and tomorrow’s PCs. While ARM chipsets may be primarily built into phones and tablets today, in the future ARM will be significant on the PC hardware platform as well. These environments currently have intense browser competition that benefits both users and developers. When you expand the view of the PC to cover a much wider range of form factors and designs as Microsoft and others forecast, it’s easy to imagine Windows running on ARM in laptops, tablets, phones, and a whole range of devices. That means users will only have one browser choice whenever there’s a Windows ARM environment.

We encourage Microsoft to remain firm on its user choice principles. Excluding 3rd party browsers contradicts Microsoft’s own published Principles that users and developers have relied upon for years. These principles represented a Microsoft market approach that was both notable and went above and beyond their DOJ antitrust settlement obligations.

Because Windows on ARM relies upon so many traditional Windows assets, including brand, code, footprint, and experience, the decision to exclude other browsers may also have antitrust implications. If Windows on ARM is simply another version of Windows on new hardware, it also runs afoul of the EC browser choice commitments and seems to represent the very behavior the DOJ-Microsoft settlement sought to prohibit.

The prospect that the next generation of Windows on ARM devices would limit users to one browser is untenable and represents a first step toward a new platform lock-in. It doesn’t have to be this way.  In announcing the Windows Principles, Microsoft’s General Counsel, Brad Smith, stated “As creators of an operating system used so widely around the world, we recognize that we have a special responsibility, both to advance innovation and to help preserve competition in the information technology industry.”  We encourage Microsoft to remain firm on its user choice principles and reject the temptation to pursue a closed path. The world doesn’t need another closed proprietary environment and Microsoft has the chance to be so much more.

– Harvey Anderson, Mozilla General Counsel

69 comments on “Windows on ARM Users Need Browser Choice Too”

  1. Ping from The problem with Microsoft trying to be Apple – CNN : Education Technology on

    […] browser maker Mozilla fired off an angry blog post earlier this month lambasting Microsoft for “an unwelcome return to the digital dark […]

  2. Ping from The problem with Microsoft trying to be Apple on

    […] browser maker Mozilla fired off an angry blog post earlier this month lambasting Microsoft for “an unwelcome return to the digital dark […]

  3. Ping from The problem with Microsoft trying to be Apple - | on

    […] browser maker Mozilla fired off an angry blog post earlier this month lambasting Microsoft for “an unwelcome return to the digital dark […]

  4. Ping from The problem with Microsoft trying to be Apple | G7Finance.com - Finance News & Personal Finance Resources on

    […] browser maker Mozilla fired off an angry blog post earlier this month lambasting Microsoft for “an unwelcome return to the digital dark […]

  5. Ping from Knowledge Management » Blog Archive » The problem with Microsoft trying to be Apple on

    […] browser maker Mozilla fired off an angry blog post earlier this month lambasting Microsoft for “an unwelcome return to the digital dark […]

  6. Ping from The problem with Microsoft trying to be Apple - itCom Blog on

    […] browser maker Mozilla fired off an angry blog post earlier this month lambasting Microsoft for “an unwelcome return to the digital dark […]

  7. Ping from What is and isn’t dead in Windows 8 - Arsanth on

    […] low-training-cost Office & IE experience on Windows 8. Despite the specific enterprise niche, a politically-charged issue of “consumer choice” has been cited by Mozilla, whos browser product (just like Visual Studio and the multitude of games published by Microsoft) […]

  8. Ping from The problem with Microsoft trying to be Apple - Open Source Portal - Business | Open Source Portal – Business on

    […] browser builder Mozilla dismissed off an angry blog post progressing this month lambasting Microsoft for “an unwelcome lapse to a digital dim […]

  9. Ping from Microsoft bans Firefox on ARM-based Windows, Mozilla says | Help Desk on

    […] Anderson has been discussing the matter with his counterparts at Microsoft, but the company hasn’t budged, he said. Anderson also detailed concerns in a blog post. […]

  10. Ping from Mozilla calls Windows RT a return to the ‘digital dark ages’ for limiting browser choice, Google nods in agreement – May 10, 2012 at 08:28AM | Lifestream on

    […]  |  Mozilla  | Email […]

  11. Ping from iGeeky » Mozilla calls Windows RT a return to the ‘digital dark ages’ for limiting browser choice, Google nods in agreement on

    […] | Mozilla | Email this | […]

  12. Ping from Browser wars flare in mobile space on

    […] Harvey Anderson complained in a blog post that Microsoft is limiting the "advanced" capabilities for outside software, effectively shutting […]

  13. Ping from Browser wars flare in mobile space on

    […] Harvey Anderson complained in a blog post that Microsoft is limiting the “advanced” capabilities for outside software, […]

  14. Ping from iApps :: Get a New customised App for iPhone iPad software developers based on Sunshine Coast Queensland for increase business exposure profits and efficiency on

    […] Harvey Anderson complained in a blog post that Microsoft is limiting the “advanced” capabilities for outside software, […]

  15. Ping from No Firefox on Windows 8 ARM Tablets | iBuzz Tech on

    […] In a post on Mozilla’s blog titled “Windows on ARM Users Need Browser Choice Too”, Mozilla’s General Counsel Harvey Anderson states: Why does this matter to users? Quite simply because Windows on ARM -as currently designed- restricts user choice, reduces competition and chills innovation.  By allowing only IE to perform the advanced functions of a modern Web browser, third-party browsers are effectively excluded from the platform. This matters for users of today’s tablets and tomorrow’s PCs […]

  16. Ping from The importance of openness | Beyond the Code on

    […] that we – and our children – will be living in. Which future do we want? Do we want choice? Do we want to limit innovation to large companies or do we want everyone to have the opportunity […]

  17. Ping from Can Mozilla right the ship? « I Web Guy Blog on

    […] RT. The ARM processor variant of Windows 8, Mozilla general counsel Harvey Anderson wrote in an official blog post, will only allow IE to run in the full Windows Classic […]

  18. Ping from The Death of Internet Explorer | LeaderGates on

    […] Classic’ environment,” explained Mozilla General Counsel Harvey Anderson in a blog post last […]

  19. Ping from Try Chrome in Metro mode | ChromeBytes on

    […] Windows 8 on x86. (Chrome won’t run in WinRT, i.e. Windows 8 on ARM processors, as Microsoft is not allowing browsers other than Internet Explorer on the platform.) If you’re running the Release Preview of Windows […]

  20. Ping from Google Readies Chrome for Windows 8 Metro | MGNom Blogs on

    […] Metro interface on desktop PCs, Google faces the same Microsoft platform restrictions Mozilla has spoken out against and as of now there will be no version of Chrome for WinRT, the version of Windows 8 designed to […]

  21. Ping from Google Readies Chrome for Windows 8 Metro | Web Hosting Blog on

    […] Metro interface on desktop PCs, Google faces the same Microsoft platform restrictions Mozilla has spoken out against and as of now there will be no version of Chrome for WinRT, the version of Windows 8 designed to […]

  22. Ping from Google mostra um pouquinho do Chrome para interface Metro do Windows 8 | Guia do PC on

    […] ele não vai poder ser configurado como navegador principal do seu sistema, isso porque a Microsoft bloqueia o acesso mais “profundo” do sistema operacional, impedindo que apps de terceiros possam ser definidos como padrões em cima dos apps nativos. Pois […]

  23. Ping from Google mostra um pouquinho do Chrome para interface Metro do Windows 8 | Blogueiros BR on

    […] ele não vai poder ser configurado como navegador principal do seu sistema, isso porque a Microsoft bloqueia o acesso mais “profundo” do sistema operacional, impedindo que apps de terceiros possam ser definidos como padrões em cima dos apps nativos. Pois […]

  24. Ping from Google Readies Chrome for Windows 8 Metro – Wired News « « on

    […] Metro interface on desktop PCs, Google faces the same Microsoft platform restrictions Mozilla has spoken out against and as of now there will be no version of Chrome for WinRT, the version of Windows 8 designed to […]

  25. Ping from Google Readies Chrome for Windows 8 Metro | on

    […] Metro interface on desktop PCs, Google faces the same Microsoft platform restrictions Mozilla has spoken out against and as of now there will be no version of Chrome for WinRT, the version of Windows 8 designed to […]

  26. Ping from Google mostra um pouquinho do Chrome para interface Metro do Windows 8 | Magus Host on

    […] não vai poder ser configurado como navegador principal do seu sistema, isso porque a Microsoft bloqueia o acesso mais “profundo” do sistema operacional, impedindo que apps de terceiros possam ser definidos como padrões em cima dos apps nativos. Pois […]

  27. Ping from Windows RT for ARM Devices Raises Old Fears of IE Browser Monopoly - Fundamental Technology Partners Inc. on

    […] on the other hand, blew a gasket. In a blog post last month, Mozilla Foundation Legal Counsel Harvey Anderson argued that Microsoft’s browser practices in Windows RT “signal an unwelcome return to the […]

  28. Ping from Google: Chrome for Windows 8 Metro coming soon | GizmoNews.Info on

    […] is also working on a Metro version of Firefox. The company recently published a blog stating that users of Windows RT also deserve a choice of browsers, and called on Microsoft to remain firm on its user choice […]

  29. Ping from Google Readies Chrome for Windows 8 Metro | Biz Op Geek on

    […] Metro interface on desktop PCs, Google faces the same Microsoft platform restrictions Mozilla has spoken out against and as of now there will be no version of Chrome for WinRT, the version of Windows 8 designed to […]

  30. Ping from Mozilla denuncia públicamente limitación de browsers en Windows RT « on

    […] ha denunciado públicamente a través de su blog la actitud de la compañía de Redmond con la competencia en el ámbito de los navegadores web al […]

  31. Ping from Acusan a Microsoft de bloquear los navegadores rivales en Windows 8 RT | SiliconWeek.com on

    […] de Firefox basada en Metro. Pero este proyecto podría complicarse ahora que la organización denuncia que la intención de Microsoft es limitar la libre elección de los usuarios y perjudicar a los […]

  32. Ping from Tech wars starring Microsoft: social search and browser-fight deja vu | Good Morning Silicon Valley on

    […] Firefox maker Mozilla’s general counsel Harvey Anderson aired his problem with that in a blog post Wednesday, saying Microsoft is preparing for “an unwelcome return to the digital dark ages […]

  33. Ping from Is Google's slow Chrome for iOS a preview of Windows RT? on

    […] of Metro apps face, and about which both Mozilla and Google have complained bitterly. In a formal statement last May, Mozilla General Counsel Harvey Anderson accused Microsoft of “platform lock-in.” In […]

  34. Ping from Linux Caracas - Windows RT limita de facto el uso de otros navegadores y Mozilla se queja on

    […] | Mozilla Blog Imagen | […]

  35. Ping from Why you won’t want to use a Windows 8 ARM tablet? | Tekosaur on

    […] to Mozilla, Microsoft plans to allow only Internet Explorer on coming Windows 8 ARM based […]

  36. Ping from best iphone and ipad apps, apps for iphone, apps for ipad, apps for mobile devices » Maven Web Browser+ on

    […] Maven Web Browser: um navegador cheio de recursos (atualizado 5x)Windows on ARM Users Need Browser Choice Too […]

  37. Ping from Mozilla, Google Take Microsoft Back to the Future With Browser Complaint | LATEST TECH BLOG on

    […] a post by Harvey Anderson, Mozilla’s general counsel, offers an indication, if not a threat, on what the maker of the […]

  38. Ping from Mozilla, Google riled over Windows 8 ARM browser limitations | LATEST TECH BLOG on

    […] at Mozilla, via […]

  39. Ping from Mozilla, Google Aren't Happy About IE-Only Windows RT | Techli on

    […] a critique posted to the Mozilla blog Wednesday, Mozilla general counsel Harvey Anderson recalled the period […]

  40. Ping from EU trustbusters tire of Microsoft tricks, probe Windows 8 – BetaNews | See Global News on

    […] Firefox project, and Harvey Anderson, Mozilla’s general counsel. Harvey Anderson made a public post about it on the Mozilla official blog back in May 2012 with direct antitrust […]

  41. Ping from Acharnement dans le contexte d’une rafale de décisions erratiques ? on

    […] il fallait s’y attendre (on est quand même aux États-Unis), on crie au monopole, on invoque la loi antitrust et on porte plainte en haut lieu. Tant et si bien qu’à ce qu’il […]

  42. Ping from Your Questions About Really Dirty Sex Questions To Ask A Guy | Stop Jealousy on

    […] SolutionsFlash Builder 4.5 Random Chat Site / Script Fix8 Apps to Chat with Random StrangersWindows on ARM Users Need Browser Choice Too82 Interesting Questions To Ask A GuyAre You Falling for the Just the Tip Sex ExcuseChinese version […]

  43. Ping from Mozilla niezadowolona z ograniczeń w systemie Windows 8 na platformę ARM - Centrum Windows on

    […] We wpisie na blogu fundacji, główny adwokat Harvey Anderson napisał, że Windows na procesory ARM, w bieżącej postaci, ogranicza wybór oraz zmniejsza konkurencję i innowacyjność. Poprzez zezwolenie na uruchomianie tylko Internet Explorera do zaawansowanych zadań nowoczesnej przeglądarki jest wykluczaniem innych przeglądarek. Ma to znaczenie dla użytkowników dzisiejszych tabletów i nowych komputerów. Anderson dodaje także, że procesory ARM wykorzystywane są aktualnie głównie w tabletach i smartfonach, ale nie ma przeciwwskazań do tego, aby takie procesory zagościły także w klasycznych komputerach. Według niego to środowisko wpływa znacząco na konkurencję wśród przeglądarek, która jest pozytywnym zjawiskiem z punktu widzenia zarówno użytkownika jak i programistów. Jeśli rozszerzymy pojęcie komputera do większej ilości urządzeń i projektów, tak jak to Microsoft i inni przewidują, łatwo wyobrazić sobie system Windows uruchomiony na procesorze ARM w laptopach, tabletach, telefonach i całym rodzaju innych urządzeń. Oznacza to, że użytkownicy do wyboru będą mieć tylko jedną przeglądarkę. […]

  44. Ping from Windows RT for ARM Devices Raises Old Fears of IE Browser Monopoly | LATEST TECH BLOG on

    […] on the other hand, blew a gasket. In a blog post last month, Mozilla Foundation Legal Counsel Harvey Anderson argued that Microsoft’s browser practices in Windows RT “signal an unwelcome return to the […]

  45. Ping from Poll: Would you consider the Microsoft Surface for Windows RT tablet at $199? | Android and Me on

    […] their Chrome browser, but unfortunately Chrome will only run on Windows 8 for x86. Microsoft is not allowing browsers other than Internet Explorer on the Windows RT […]

  46. Ping from Poll: Would you consider the Microsoft Surface for Windows RT tablet at $199? | test on

    […] their Chrome browser, but unfortunately Chrome will only run on Windows 8 for x86. Microsoft is not allowing browsers other than Internet Explorer on the Windows RT […]

  47. Ping from Poll: Would you consider the Microsoft Surface for Windows RT tablet at $199? | ssandroid.com on

    […] their Chrome browser, but unfortunately Chrome will only run on Windows 8 for x86. Microsoft is not allowing browsers other than Internet Explorer on the Windows RT […]

  48. Ping from Poll: Would you consider the Microsoft Surface for Windows RT tablet at $199? | Androidster on

    […] their Chrome browser, but unfortunately Chrome will only run on Windows 8 for x86. Microsoft is not allowing browsers other than Internet Explorer on the Windows RT […]

  49. Ping from Poll: Would you consider the Microsoft Surface for Windows RT tablet at $199? | Android News on

    […] their Chrome browser, but unfortunately Chrome will only run on Windows 8 for x86. Microsoft is not allowing browsers other than Internet Explorer on the Windows RT […]

  50. Ping from Allegations multiply in EU browser probe of Microsoft | Desktops on

    […] the alleged violations, Mozilla has been vocal about the browser choice screen and Windows RT. In a May blog post, Mozilla’s chief counsel, Harvey Anderson, argued that Windows RT should be held to the same […]

More comments:1 2